DC SpecialCast #23 – Secret Origins of Super-Villains!

Two-Face! Grodd! Dr. Light! Ever wonder how they got their villainous starts? Well, listen in, as Ward Hill Terry joins Paul to discuss DC Super Stars #14 – Secret Origins of Super-Villains! Plus, the Monthly Planet with Shawn M. Myers!

This month’s instocktrades.com selections:

https://www.instocktrades.com/products/may257251/dc-finest-hawkman-wings-across-time-tp

https://www.instocktrades.com/products/jun257234/two-face-trial-separation-tp

Check out Terry’s band:

https://stopcallingmefrank.bandcamp.com/track/my-baby-is-an-axe-murder-from-wisconsin

Visit the Daily Planet:

https://www.mikesamazingworld.com/F231EB71A50CE9/features/gallery.php?page=planet

Who is Ed Davis?

https://www.mikesamazingworld.com/main/features/creator.php?creatorid=968

https://www.nga.gov/artists/48196-ed-davis

https://leagueofcomicgeeks.com/people/7638/ed-davis/comics

https://www.tcj.com/the-1982-neal-adams-interview/

All about Doctors from TwoMorrows:

https://twomorrows.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=98_54&products_id=1884&zenid=0cr808oll9ku8n8fhq8a6k98r3

Have a question or comment?  Have a specific issue you love and want to talk to us about it?  Have a favorite issue and want to be a guest? 

Subscribe to DC SpecialCast:

This podcast is a proud member of the FIRE AND WATER PODCAST NETWORK:

“Cloud Dancer ” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)

Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License

http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

18 responses to “DC SpecialCast #23 – Secret Origins of Super-Villains!”

  1. I dont like compelcating Two-face so much. Thrown acid is weird enough. Thrown acid, meant for cop-guy, deflected by Batman into exactly half Harvey’s face (but not his eye) That’s complex geometry! (grin)

  2. Samurai legend : in the ancient days of your
    It was believed that Harvey dent .
    Was on pulp hero who attorney who was blinded by gangsters and do to surgery gained night vision.
    The hero’s name I can’t remember.
    Wonder full episode.
    I’d say the two face was my favorite this issue.
    Though my brothers favorite would probably be dr light mainly because of his connection to titans.

  3. Learn something new everyday. Case in point: I’d never heard of Ed Davis before, but based on your spotlight about him and the images in your gallery page, I find myself wishing that he had done more comics work. Really nice stuff – and I’m always pleased to see a fellow Ed getting some love.
    And man, I so remember that Monthly Planet with the softball game news – since at the time I was much more of a Marvel kid, I remember being a bit peeved over the caricatured depictions of the Marvel heroes. By the way, on the topic of Welcome Back, Kotter and ‘absent’ characters, i.e., those who get mentioned but never appear on screen (like Norm’s wife in Cheers), I recall that Mr. Kotter often told anecdotes about his bigger-than-life high-school buddy named ‘Bonzo Maretti.’
    Also, love that the image from the Super Hero Dictionary includes the entry for ‘bud’ – I noted how expectantly Jonna Crisp is observing the potted plant, given that “Many buds would grow in the next few days.” I’m guessing Jonna also makes an appearance in the dictionary’s entry for ‘rolling paper’.

  4. I know I’m an easy mark for Jim Aparo, but man do I love that cover. It’s so eye popping!

    I am completely unfamiliar with Ed Davis’ work, but I didn’t think it was too bad. Definitely fits in the Neal Adams/Mike Nasser/Rich Buckler style of dynamic realism.

    Hawkman just looks WRONG about without wings on his head.

  5. When was Gorilla City revealed to the world, Paul? Probably off-panel as regards this story, I don’t remember Gorilla City going public in the Bronze Age. It did go public in the JLApe event decades later, in 1999. I have crushed your faith in me.

    What a great spin on the usual Secret Origins format this issue is, it’s not stuff we already know all the way through, but origins revamped and sequelled. It’s funny, though, that the Dr Light and Grodd stories were declared non-canonical, and the new stuff in the Two-Face strip was never referenced again.

    Wow, the Ed Davies mystery! As well as Captain Entropy, maybe Rich and Max, the Werid Warriors, might know something on the military side.

    i always found the original Shark terrifying. Gil Kane made him look like he really would eat you, it was the predator’s eyes.

    I suspect Paul Kupperberg had Hawkman be the first JLAer to meet Dr Light in a previously unrevealed tale because Arthur’s first encounter with the Justice League happened a few years before Carter joined, so there’s no need to ask why the League members hadn’t heard of him. Maybe Paul K doesn’t recall this because it was editor Paul Levitz’s idea.

    Loved the Monthly Planet, as ever. As regards Superman 308 changing Superman and Supergirl’s whole origins, if DC had saved it for an anniversary issue the readers might have actually gone in believing it might be true. Then again, when I bought this as a kid I was entertained enough by the question of why Supergirl was hoaxing her cousin, which she obviously was.

    Which brings us to the retroactive continuity question. Wasn’t the term ‘retroactive continuity’ termed about a decade later in Roy Thomas’ All-Star Squadron to cover new characters and story elements that ‘weren’t shown’ in the Golden Age? The existence of Danette Riley as sister of the original Firebrand, the Quality characters ‘originating’ on Earth 2 and crossing worlds… that kind of thing.

    Did I hear something about the Daily Planet pages being in a gallery somewhere? Can we have them in the regular gallery, please?

    i’m intrigued by that Unknown Soldier story, the idea that his death would wreck the morale of the D Day forces… I’m pretty sure everyone was rather more motivated than that. And wasn’t the Unknown Soldier a secret?

    Shawn, Misty from that Superboy story never shows up again, which is for the best.

    1
    1. I believe this DC SUPER-STARS story was the *only* reference to Gorilla City revealing themselves to the world in DC Comics published in the 1970s. The first reference to the Gorilla City reveal in a Flash story was in THE FLASH #295 (Feb 1981), which was a story where Gorilla City decided to undo it all by making everyone on Earth forget Gorilla City ever existed…

      2
  6. Impressive podcast most impressive. So… like your work and respect the effort you put into it. But, …. I have a slight issue. And I realize.i will probably be the only person here who cares. However…. Please don’t misgender Ms. Jenny Isabela or dead name her. If ya want to say formally know as Tonny then hit with Jenny .

    . So please don’t misgender a trans woman. Doesn’t mater if you like her or not. I like most of your coverage and old stories you have brought up. But, please no on that . I realize you probably don’t mean anything by it. It’s not something that I feel should be done. Misgendering that is

    Moving on. The cover is fine. The Green Lantern story happened… that’s all I got. lol next. The two face art was really good. Sad he didn’t do more work. The story telling is well done.

    Good writing for the time. Very aspheric. With the lighting and use of shadow. Specifically, with the black-and-white artwork that he gave are sold to Walt Simonson. He definitely did a great job of shading for that.ah well is what it is . NExt

    . Ya know…. So I use to wonder why they put wings on Hawk Man’s mask. Now…. I see why. Good Grief… not exactly looking like a Stacy London picked out costume.it looks like the 70s Bat Girl put it on him. Speaking of tacky, dear word, who told Doctor like to dress like Bill Nye, the science guy?

    Also did his light powers make him age backwards because and all the doom patrol issues he has black hair and a beard well that unique Van Dyke without a mustache or whatever that type of facial hair is called

    You can tell he’s single no one would let him exit the house wearing that outfit or if you were a gay man no gay man would let him wear that thing in public. Elton John would have to stop him and go. Please no that is too tacky.

    Maybe it would be fine with a different Tie. Just bowties seem to work with an outfit different than what he’s sporting. And the hair geez… never higher a drunk hairdresser. He makes Wolverine look like he made a good choice in hair dos. Heck the wig Magpie wore in her first appearance was better.

    Oy vey. Next lol yeah it’s a giant bubble Shaws right . Wait …. White people weren’t good at the M. Arts in the 60s? Huh someone should tell Gene Labelle, Bill “ Super Foot “ Wallace , Mike Stone, Bob Wall and Joe Lewis ( the
    Martial arts guy not the boxer.) since he envied America Kick Boxing. Well started it here in this country.

    Or Ed Parker the guy with the convention that first featured Bruce Lee doing JKD to the world. He should have gotten more of a spotlight… but, in the 70s Marvel put out Shang Chi. So there was that . And hey Shang Chi has a movie .

    Have we even seen Richard Dragon in Live Action? Nope. Though the cartoon making him a hot Asian guy that was James Bond level of cool is there . Anyway keep on board casting peace.

    1. The good news is that Jenny would be OK if she heard this podcast, as per this interview with The Beat when she announced her trans status back in February.

      https://www.comicsbeat.com/isabella-trans/

      It’s worth reading the whole article, but here’s a relevant paragraph:

      ************
      She elaborates that she doesn’t consider “Tony Isabella” a deadname, explaining she plans to use both. When asked by DC about reprints of her old work, she responded, “Going forward, I’ll be writing under both names as I am already doing with Last Kiss [the comic strip she co-writes]. Whether I use Tony or Jenny will depend on the project. For example, if I were to write another Black Lightning series, it would make sense on several levels, including commercial, for me to go with Tony. If I were to write a series starring his daughters, Jenny might be more appropriate. I haven’t yet decided which name will go on my new trans super-hero series. It could be both.”
      ************

      Away from, Jenny, not all gay men are clothes obsessives!

        1. Also I don’t think I said gay men were cloths obsessed. Just that why anyone would let Dr. Light go out looking like that was ah geeez. Sorry if it seems to imply that it was not my intent. It was a joke about Dr. Light’s cloths .

          I meant not to put any stero types on any one. But, sorry if what I said was insulting.

  7. Great discussion gents! It’s funny that you guys bring up “retcons” and debate about what constitutes one…because (at least) 2/3rds of this issue were retconned out of DC continuity by the 80s! Not only did Isabella refute Hawkman’s involvement in the Dr. Light story, but the Gorilla City origin got dissed in that locale’s Who’s Who entry: “The origin of Gorilla City is unknown. One published account allleges that the city orginally existed on the planet Calor, and that the gorillas mentally tapped the energy in Green Lantern’s power ring to transport them to Earth (see Green Lantern II). This account is clearly erroneous, since the second Flash (see The Flash II) first visited Gorilla City on Earth before Hal Jordan ever became Green Lantern.” One of the few times Who’s Who referenced “erroneous” published accounts (see also Mopee..or don’t, since he didn’t get a Who’s Who entry!).

    I don’t think Two-Face’s origin changes were addressed anywhere, but clearly Maroni only had Dent in mind for a target in every telling before or since. So the whole comic has been “debunked”. Doesn’t make it a bad comic, though.

    Personally, I would consider all the stories in this issue as retcons. If a later creator goes back beyond what was originally established and adds elments, it’s a retcon. Thomas Wayne as the first Batman is a retcon, Bruce Wayne wearing the Robin costume first is a retcon, for instance.

    Speaking of retcons, all those Superboy stories where he met characters he would know as Superman first (publishing-wise) would be retcons to me. And Superboy met young Bruce Wayne a few times, including one story where Bruce assumed the identity of “The Flyiing Fox”. These were recounted in Roy Thomas’continuity house cleaning anniversary issue, World’s Finest #271, that recounted ALL the origins of the Superman/Batman team. One of my all-time favorite comics!

    The Monthly Planet was fun as always, and great to see Shawn pull out his DC Super Dictionary! I love mine! Last year for Christmas, Cindy gifted me some of the companion Super A educational magazines used in schools!

    2
    1. Quite right, Uncle Chris. To clarify the WHO’S WHO Gorilla City entry claim, the Flash first fought Gorilla Grodd in THE FLASH #106 (May 1959), which was published five months before Hal Jordan first became Green Lantern in SHOWCASE #22 (Oct 1959), and over a year before Hal Jordan traveled to Calor in GREEN LANTERN #1 (Aug 1960)…

      And Dr. Light’s WHO’S WHO entry also refuted Katar Hol’s involvement in the DC SUPER-STARS Doctor Light story as well, referring only to “A Thanagarian lawman” in the entry’s recap of this tale. At first, I thought Peter Sanderson’s research may had pointed out that the DCSS story didn’t quite fit in Hawkman’s history, but now I am inclined to believe it was Ms. Isabella’s refutation of it in the letters page of SHADOW WAR OF THE HAWKMAN #2 (which stated that “maybe some *other* Thanagarian policeman fought the Doc at that time”) that prompted this revision. SHADOW WAR OF THE HAWKMAN #2 was released on Febuary 12, 1985, more than two months before WHO’S WHO #6 (April 30, 1985)…

      Only Two-Face’s WHO’S WHO entry recognizes his DCSS origin update/continuation in its entirety…

      2
  8. So much fun.
    Like many, I love the cover and, in particular, I really like Two-Face. He’s my favorite Batman villain.
    For sure I read this at some point because I remember the wonkiness of the GL addition to Grodd’s story. Whenever I read it, I said to myself ‘this Grodd stuff isn’t going to stick’. Then to have Dr. Light’s device open up a portal to Thanagar and an optic lab on Thanagar to boot, I said ‘there is suspension of disbelief and there is disintegration of disbelief’. Yes, I can believe in green energy wish rings and anti-grav metal. But all this other stuff seems unnecessary. If Luthor can make stuff, Light can too.

    Even the addition to Two-Face seems wrong. I always though Maroni knew he was going up the river and just wanted revenge on Dent. Simple enough.

    Anyways, I may have to find and reread given the discussion.

    As for the Monthly Planet, hooray more of that Superman story being covered. That story is bat-guano crazy and I am here for it. The JLGL stuff is delicious.

    And for Sean, that Supergirl pic in the ‘bubble’ definition is Bob Oksner, lifted from the cover of Adventure Comics #417!

    Love the show!

    2
  9. So many of my favorite villains are in this book! I am a big Gorilla Grodd fan, but I am not a fan of him having extraterrestrial origins. I can suspend disbelief enough for the countless alien races who are physically indistinguishable from humans, but not that they have animals who look exactly like those on Earth. As much as I love Krypto, it was always funny to me that Krypton had dogs along with the thought beasts, drangs, and other weird creatures. And I guess they needed a space-faring hero to be involved in this story, but I found myself missing The Flash a bit.

    IMHO, I consider Brainiac to be Superman’s top villain since Lex has become more or less part of the supporting cast these days. Many voices on the F&W Network have wondered why Brainiac hasn’t been featured in a film yet and it’s a mystery to me too. Glad to see he will (hopefully) get his due in Man of Tomorrow.

    Two-Face is, along with Scarecrow, my favorite Bat-villain. He is also the one comic book character that I have cosplayed at Halloween a few years back thanks to my wife who was Catwoman.

    The Shark never made much of an impression on me. And the one thing I remember about Dr. Light is how he was booted from the Fearsome Five when Psimon replaced him as the leader.

    The Monthly Planet is always a joy, but this month, it was tempered by that darn PHP bug that has taken out Mike’s Amazing World of Comics. This is why we can’t have nice things, I guess.

    Great show as always, Paul, Shawn, and Terry.

  10. Great episode, guys!

    Interesting history on Ed Davis — no relation that I know of. I’m sure that if my father had a brother or nephew or someone closely related that drew comics, he would have said something to me. His story art is good, but that piece of his that Simonson shared is great!! Considering the mystery of his whereabouts, I wonder how much of his emotion is shown in that.

    The whole thing about the Gorilla City inhabitants being from another planet seems like that origin for the immortals in “Highlander II: The Quickening”. It didn’t work there, but it seems to work better here.

    So, if Arthur Light had grabbed a different box on Thanagar, would he have been known as Dr. Flight? (I hear the groans, people)

    On a slightly different topic, how publicized was Jenny Isabella’s transition? I first heard about her a couple of weeks ago. A YouTube short about Black Vulcan mentioned a Jenny Blake Isabella. At first, I thought it was really bad AI slop until I googled her name.

  11. Quick continuity question: have the Superman newspaper strips been attributed to the Superman of a certain pre-Crisis Earth? I ask because it sure would be great to have this proto-Brainiac be a foe of the Superman of Earth-2. Anyone have any knowledge one way or the other?

    Quick continuity comment: about The Shark. I was a reader of the Superboy series by Karl Kesel and Tom Grummett. When King Shark was introduced, there was a brief origin and it was said that King Shark was the son of “a shark god”. When I asked Karl Kesel about that on Facebook, I asked if it was a hint that The Shark was King Shark’s father. He confirmed that it was! It was something he slipped in and never followed up on, but he seemed happy to know someone caught that.

    Quick continuity nerdiness: wouldn’t it be cool if the upcoming “People VS Gorilla Grodd” HBO series poaches a bit of this crazy Grodd origin story to have a younger Green Lantern Kyle Chandler face off against Grodd in the past? Well, I think it would be cool.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *